Dating is a minefield, but so is the human brain, which processes love and fumbles it in equal measure. In A Very Merry Breakup, writer/director/producer/actor Elizabeth Guest draws from her own experiences to both address and poke fun at a very real struggle for people when it comes to love. While it’s hard to call this a proper holiday film, the universal struggle at its heart makes it a decent enough watch, even if certain moments will have you cringe and reflect on your own dating mistakes.
A Very Merry Breakup centers on Lydia (Elizabeth Guest), a self-professed love addict who is her own worst enemy. Just as she thinks she’s ready to settle down with her green-flag of a boyfriend, Tim (Andrew Leeds), she freaks out and jumps ship, breaking off the relationship to run back home to Los Angeles for a fresh start and to try to break these self-defeating habits that are ruining her life and her grasp on happiness.
She has a lot of work to do to address these issues, and A Very Merry Breakup spends the first third of the film building up the case for why Lydia is a hot mess. There’s a high that comes with a new relationship and being wanted, and stability cuts against that high. In fact, it puts a hard stop on the alluring thrill of being chased. Without that constant adrenaline cycle that comes with the pursuit of love, it’s no surprise that Lydia would accidentally ruin the closest thing to a good relationship she’s had in a long while.
Elizabeth Guest nails the balance of comedy and cringe in A Very Merry Breakup.

And what comes after her breakup isn’t great. Her love prospects throughout the film are dismal, but don’t expect good judgment to come easily to Lydia or those around her. Lydia makes a lot of bad choices that are hard to watch at times, even as Guest rides the line between comedy and cringe in her performance and timing, finding the special touch that makes Lydia arguably likable.
Moral implications of her actions aside (seriously, there is a lot in need of forgiveness), the growth Lydia exhibits by the end is what makes A Very Merry Breakup worth the watch. What does bog down some of the humor, pushing elements from funny to cringe territory, are Lydia’s parents. As a newcomer to Guest’s work, knowing that some of the parental dynamic carries over from Guest’s previous web series made me wonder whether context was missing.
The parents themselves are particularly zany, but sometimes their little side jokes and quips get lost in translation, almost as if they were in another movie altogether. That’s not to say that the characterization isn’t there.
The road to change can get really ugly, but Lydia grows by confronting her mistakes.
The codependent nature of Lydia’s relationship with all four of her parents emerges in different ways, reinforcing how returning home is a barrier to tackling the problematic behaviors she’s trying to address. Each parent has quirks that make them initially interesting, but they are then used repeatedly, stripping those idiosyncrasies of depth and specialness and making them one-note.
When things finally reach their zenith at the climactic party meant to be helpful rather than perpetuating bad decisions, Guest’s ability to encapsulate the overwhelming emotions on camera and through the generalized sense of chaos onscreen is well-executed. It also reminds us that interventions aren’t the only way to deliver much-needed wake-up calls. Sometimes it can be a party your parents throw in an ill-advised attempt at matchmaking.
While A Very Merry Breakup may not be the feel-good holiday movie of the year, it reminds us that timing is everything when it comes to big life changes. And sometimes those big life changes can’t really happen without finally tackling the parts of ourselves we’ve been ignoring for years. Elizabeth Guest’s Lydia is messy, but through her journey in A Very Merry Breakup, awkwardness and all, audiences get to see how sometimes, to make changes, we’ve got to go through some mega-cringey moments. And this film has plenty.
A Very Merry Breakup is available now on Digital.
Rating
While A Very Merry Breakup may not be the feel-good holiday movie of the year, it reminds us that timing is everything when it comes to change.







