Guarding Stars will have you guarding your heart against leading man Jared Padalecki’s natural charm and charisma in the latest Netflix holiday rom-com. Starring Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki, this holiday film hits familiar territory with a twist, throwing an all-too-serious bodyguard and a carefree blockbuster action star together in a tale that reminds them of the love—both familial and romantic—they’re missing from their lives.
Bodyguard Hanna Brooks (Leighton Meester) takes her job seriously. With her innocuous appearance both a blessing and a curse in her profession, she spends her days tackling assignments efficiently before going home to an empty house. It’s not for a lack of trying. Through a quick-paced exchange of words on the job with her ex/colleague (Toby Sandeman), she has tried to date with little success. For the most part, Guarding Stars makes it clear that Hanna is wound up tight and can’t let loose anymore. Work is all she has.
Enter a contract featuring Jack Stapleton (Jared Padalecki), the popular action film star with a stalker on his tail. His studio is worried about his safety, so they’ve hired Hanna and her team to get him in and out of Montana undetected to visit his mom (Andie MacDowell) after her surgery. Of course, Jack doesn’t really know how to stick to the script or follow orders, which forces Hanna to pretend she’s his girlfriend. With a change in plans for Jack to stay for the holidays, the two are forced to play make-believe to keep Jack safe for Christmas.
Jared Padalecki leans into his natural comedic timing and charm in Guarding Stars.

While the romance could have used a little more time to cook (something Guarding Stars pokes fun at a tad in the film’s final scene before credits), there’s no denying how easily Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki interact onscreen as their characters. Still, the chemistry isn’t quite enough to sell the romance meant to spark between them, and the film’s third act doesn’t help either. Separately, however, both easily fill their characters’ trope-ish opposites-attract personality traits.
Everything leading up to the third act flows with an air of comforting predictability, with Hanna’s and Jack’s relationship with death, along with their desire for familial connection, being their way to connect beyond the scope of their fake-relationship scheme. However, the contrived and rushed execution of the stalker’s identity reveal, and the ripple effect of that person’s obsession, does no favors to the couple’s development onscreen, or really the story altogether.
Building the stalker through exposition is far more believable, with the danger heightening to a well-deserved peak in Guarding Stars. Red herrings help here, too, to a point. But once the reveal occurs, you’re left questioning what work went into fleshing out this person. The actor’s performance is, unfortunately, over the top in a way that detracts rather than adds to the character’s inherent instability. An additional twist toward the end, meant to bring the two lovebirds together, also suffers from similar issues, making the third act hard to swallow.
Guarding Stars follows a comfortable path before the third act bungles things.

It’s a shame because Guarding Stars does so much to flesh out Hanna, Jack, and their loved ones leading up to the climax. The Stapleton family is chaotic, but that chaos comes from a love that immediately draws Hanna in. There’s pain lying underneath, though, and only Hank (Noah LaLonde) is comfortable enough to voice it to Jack. With his limited screen time, LaLonde’s Hank wears his frustration toward Jack on his sleeve and delivers the right level of sarcasm and passive aggression every time they converse.
And while Hanna doesn’t have a family in the traditional sense, her coworkers are her family and have no problem keeping her in check. It’s mostly in good fun, with Sandeman’s Robbie occasionally dropping more personal zingers in line with the character’s newfound ex status. However, CM Punk’s Doghouse steals scenes. You can tell he’s having fun, and it shows in his performance.
Shot in beautiful Calgary, Guarding Stars has the perfect backdrop and premise for a relatively decent holiday romance. Unfortunately, a forced final act rushes through the ending and does little to make the romance feel earned. It’s still an okay watch for those looking for something to watch for the holidays, but it is one of the weaker ones from Netflix’s holiday rom-com collection.
Guarding Stars is now streaming exclusively on Netflix.
Guarding Stars has the perfect backdrop and premise for a relatively decent holiday romance. Unfortunately, a contrived final act rushes through the ending and does little to make the romance feel earned.






