REVIEW: ‘Nobody Wants This’ Season 3 Is A Complete Shanda

When Netflix’s Nobody Wants This first started, I thought it was a blast, with good humor despite its aggravating treatment of its female characters. By Nobody Wants This Season 3, however, I am completely over this show. It’s a total shanda, with annoying protagonists who have no chemistry.

The previously interesting plot of hot rabbi (Adam Brody) and not-Jewish sex podcaster (Kristen Bell) falling in love despite the challenges facing them has pretty much gone out the window. Instead, we get utterly passé relationship contrivances and a side plot about both of their siblings that starts out better than the main show and fizzles into something possibly worse than the main thread’s flop.

When Nobody Wants This Season 3 begins, we find Noah (Brody) and Joanne (Bell) in one of their classic situations: they’ve moved in together, but everything the other does drives them crazy. What a silly rom-com concept. Where the show looks for laughter, they find none. 

Nobody Wants This Season 3 makes everything a repetative conflict.

The show has become so terribly grating. Nearly every episode is built on some miscommunication between the two supposed lovers where Noah whines about something, Joanne is mean about it, they act like they’ve never had a real or honest conversation once in their lives together, and then some outside force comes and knocks sense back into them.

Can these two never have a normal day where they just exist and things are fine, and there’s not some relationship-shattering conflict between them? It would seem not. And neither can pretty much anything in the rest of their lives. A show needs conflict to be interesting, sure, but every conflict in Nobody Wants This Season 3 is so aggressive.

Whether it’s Joanne beefing with her conversion classmates (each of whom fulfills one annoying stereotype or another, including the rabbi leading it), or it’s Joanne beefing with Bina, her mother-in-law (Tovah Feldshuh), or it’s Joanne beefing with her sister, Morgan. Or it’s just Joanne beefing with a stranger! She cannot stop beefing with everyone around her all the time. It’s tiring, and it needs to stop. Can’t we let her have at least one healthy relationship?

The supporting characters are easily the most interesting, as Noah and Joanne suffer from tired writing.

Noah is no better. He is reduced this season to a constantly capitulating mama’s boy who seems to have been made at the golden retriever factory to make Joanne’s every whim come true at the expense of him being his own person. His scant early-season personal experiences revolve around a completely absurd workplace scenario that makes no practical sense, is offensive to people who work in those kinds of spaces, and completely stops mattering to the season’s plot the second it’s resolved.

The most interesting part of Nobody Wants This Season 3 is really its side characters. Morgan and Sasha (Timothy Simons), Noah’s brother, have been having a bit of a thing since the show started.

They’re easy to root for despite the show bungling their dynamic so horribly by the end that every bit of goodwill their plotline garnered for the show is dashed completely over the slog of the final episodes. There is one episode this season that uses some great camera and set trickery that almost had me forgiving the season some of its sins, until it bungled everything thereafter.

Despite a strong concept, Nobody Wants This Season 3 fumbles the story and characters. 

Even Esther (Jackie Tohn), Sasha’s ex-ish wife, gets better treatment this season than she has before. Perhaps the best treatment of any character this season, in fact. She gets to be an authentically independent person who makes her own decisions and isn’t defined by her relationship to anybody else, the way she had been previously.

Bina, however, the culprit of so much of the show’s rancid Jewish mother stereotyping, is worse than ever. Her antics plague the entire season. Not a single one of them is funny or charming, and each just brings out the worst in the other characters. Sarah Silverman at least joins the cast this season with an interesting character arc, but even still, she carries on a gross Netflix tradition of painting female rabbis as weird and lesser than their male counterparts.

Nobody Wants This Season 3 is deeply frustrating. The show has a neat concept, but it does less than ever to actually explore what could be interesting about an interfaith relationship. Joanne doesn’t feel nearly enough like a full human being for her to possibly explore what becoming Jewish really means to her, no matter how many times she tries to explain it. And Noah is barely a character. The side plots could have rocked, but they were fumbled even worse than the protagonists.

Nobody Wants This Season 3 is streaming now, exclusively on Netflix.

Nobody Wants This Season 2 |