It’s a holiday tradition. Sitcoms have a long history of doing episodes based around whatever the closest holiday is. Newlyweds Episode 5, “Thanksgiving,” as the title suggests, is an episode all about Jeanie (Téa Leoni) and James (Tim Daly) as they spend their first Thanksgiving together.
Something that doesn’t often get discussed in sitcoms is how a family changes after the death of one of its members. Although Newlyweds doesn’t spell it out, it’s clear that Jeanie and her kids, Lolo (Ignacio Diaz-Silverio) and Poppy (Emma Meisel), have experienced loss in their backstory.
Newlyweds Episode 5 is the second episode in which they’ve mentioned “George” in reference to Jeanie’s former husband, but it’s implied here that he’s passed. As a result, Jeanie and her kids, who are used to big family Thanksgivings, haven’t really celebrated in a few years now. James, by contrast, has always been a “less-is-more” kind of guy but wants to do right by his new wife.
Newlyweds Episode 5 tackles the tried-and-true sitcom tradition of holiday-themed episodes.

He proposes a small, intimate Thanksgiving to at least allow Jeanie and the kids a safe space to reintroduce the celebration into their lives. Of course, in true sitcom fashion, the best-laid plans sometimes just remain plans. Before long, the guest list has reached gargantuan proportions, far beyond the original scope of what was agreed to.
It starts innocuously enough: Jeanie wants to invite their mutual friend Dan (Al Madrigal) and Arvid (Bill O’Neill), but soon enough the guest list blows up from 4 to 14. Of these guests, James and Jeanie don’t even know many of them. Of course, among them is James’ ex-wife Claudia (Jamie Lee Curtis). She wasn’t invited, but that’s never stopped her from showing up before.
The rest of Newlyweds Episode 5 is predictable sitcom fare. It’s funny and incredibly relatable. One thing that stands out is the contrast between descriptions of James and Claudia’s Thanksgivings together versus what is happening this year.
The contrast between Thanksgiving celebration styles shows how James approached each relationship.
While their individual recollections of events differ greatly, one thing James and Claudia agree on is that Thanksgiving was a two-person event for the duration of their marriage because that’s the way James liked it. Newlyweds Episode 5 truly leans into the contrast of these two relationships.
With Jeanie, it’s only been a few months, and he’s already invited half the neighborhood because that’s how much he values his wife’s wants and needs. That’s not to say he wasn’t attentive to Claudia, but just that his relationship with Jeanie is so much better than it ever was with her. His priorities have clearly changed in this relationship, and Claudia certainly notices.
One of the dangers of doing this kind of episode is that, inevitably, there is a group of characters that we aren’t intended to care about and will likely be gone before the next episode. Newlyweds Episode 5 follows that same format.
Tim Daly stands out the most as James takes on the challenge of organizing a great Thanksgiving.

It’s disappointing because with so many people, there are opportunities for the main cast and even supporting cast like Dan to have a moment. Instead, even big, over-the-top characters like Claudia and Arvid end up taking a back seat to the chaos of the day. Dan’s Tinder date ends up with more to do than Claudia, which just doesn’t seem right.
While Arvid doesn’t get a chance to shine, that may not be the worst thing. He’s still much more subdued as the season goes on than he was initially, and that’s doing him a ton of favors. Because he’s not in the audience’s face every few minutes, he remains mostly tolerable. Still, it’d be nice if Newlyweds used him as more than just a punchline.
Tim Daly is the real star of Newlyweds Episode 5. Between the constant struggle of keeping his wife happy and wanting to be comfortable in his own home, Daly has a lot of character to keep track of. He checks every box in his down-to-earth portrayal of James here. Further, he allows James to experience some of the greatest character growth we’ve seen in him so far.
Newlyweds Episode 5 may fall in line with most sitcom fare, but James’s development shines bright.

Unfortunately, the only other growth we get to see is a brief tender moment from Jeanie to Claudia that isn’t reciprocated. Claudia still spends most of the episode trying to be a nuisance rather than a decent human. Jamie Lee Curtis, however, remains the most talented actor among a group of insanely talented people. It’s fun to imagine how much more scene she could chew on if given the proper opportunity.
Not surprisingly, Newlyweds Episode 5 is exactly what it promises to be: a satirical look at Thanksgiving in the life of its titular couple. It’s certainly not perfect, but it has a message about moving on from past grief and allowing for new experiences and traditions. Newlyweds Episode 5 delivers both hope and laughter in abundance.
New episodes of Newlyweds air on Friday nights on NBC and are streaming on Peacock the next day.
Previous Episode | Next Episode
Not surprisingly, Newlyweds Episode 5 is exactly what it promises to be: a satirical look at Thanksgiving in the life of its titular couple.







