You never really know someone else. Not your parents or your siblings or your lovers or your friends. Everybody has secrets, parts of themselves they don’t show to anyone else. You’ll never know another person’s thoughts, no matter how hard you try. Every person you’ve ever met is or has been lonely, and every person you ever have or will meet has felt completely and utterly alone. But that’s the thing about being alone: it looks different for every person. Nocturne Episode 5, titled “Solitude,” understands that loneliness comes in many forms.
For Jonah (Liev Schreiber), it’s in being dismissed from the case by Quinn (Poorna Jagannathan) after he refuses to deny planting the evidence that got Jurek Walter (Stephen Graham) convicted. Did he do it? Hard to say. In a flashback at the episode’s opening, we see Jonah confront Walter about the people who have gone missing. Walter denies it, of course, but he also not-so-subtly reminds Jonah that trying to intimidate him didn’t end well for Jonah’s partner… or his wife.
Jonah’s unspoken rage is key in Nocturne Episode 5.

That comment proves to be (seemingly) too much for Jonah. After a phone call from Chief Ellision (Bill Camp) informs him that they still haven’t found any evidence linking Walter to the crime, he puts on gloves and collects a sample of Walter’s spit before leaving. Schrieber has played Jonah with a mix of exhaustion, determination, resignation, and empathy for much of the show, but this scene is defined by Jonah’s unspoken rage.
Does he plant it? We don’t know. If there’s one thing Nocturne likes to do, often to great effect, it’s to deny us answers. But when Quinn asks him to deny it, he leaves instead, and she throws him off the case. It’s an interesting creative choice. If he did plant evidence, it’s hard to be upset about it. But what’s fascinating is that if he did, Jonah can’t bring himself to say so. Or maybe there’s something else entirely. We don’t know. We may never find out. I love it.
Inside Riverside, Saga (Zazie Beetz) is getting to know Walter. They’ve been speed dating through their sinks. Saga, of course, has to pretend not to be too interested, so she pulls some reverse psychology when Walter asks her if she’s a cop outright, and says “maybe.”

By playing it off like she doesn’t want him to talk to her (she actually threatens to kill him if he does), Saga basically dares him to. And it works. Beetz sells all of this, as you can see her playing Saga, playing Esther, the patient she’s posing as, and trying to figure out the right answer in real time to get what she wants.
Meanwhile, Karl (Rory Culkin) is dealing with the price of smuggling out Walter’s note, which gets him a talking-to from Nate (Gary Carr) and Quinn. The rules are simple: cooperate or go to prison. As you can imagine, he slips what’s going on to Walter. The plot thickens.
Elsewhere, Michael (Lando Valentin) and Ida (Chrissy Metz) are trying to return to a normal life after Michael comes home from the hospital. Valentin is the better of the two in these scenes, playing Michael as a boy in a lot of pain who is doing the best he can.
Nocturne Episode 5 introduces a bit of melodrama with Ida’s performance.

This subplot delivers one of Nocturne Episode 5‘s most memorable scenes. After a rather disturbing game of hangman, Ida takes Michael to a diner. He’s quickly overwhelmed by the number of people and attention (and he still doesn’t see well) when a kind waitress (Caroline Neff) comes to the rescue and lets him eat in the back.
The real moment of pathos, though, comes when she offers him dessert and he asks to eat it in the dark, inside the refrigerator. She splits the difference and brings him a slice of cake with a candle for all the birthdays he missed in captivity. It’s an excellent scene, and one that is made entire by Valentine and Neff, who turn a very small role into something memorable.
Jonah may be off the case, but a tip-off brings him to the graves of a couple of dogs who were buried alive, just like Walter’s other victims. Tracking down their collars leads him to a house where a strange man in his underwear (Ben Chase) tells him the dogs’ owners, Uncle Pat, died a couple of years ago from a fall. But this guy – to Chase’s credit – is weird and Jonah clearly doesn’t buy it.

He comes back later and finds several of what look like breathing tubes sticking out of the ground, and then he and Ellison (who shows up looking for Jonah) get into a fight with Captain Underpants and the biggest man you’ve ever seen.
Afterward, they learn that Uncle Pat hung himself over the death of his dogs. On the way home, the two piece together that Walter’s victims aren’t the people he buries: it’s the ones up top who kill themselves after they disappear. They’ve been looking for connections in the wrong place, and the realization is enough to bring in Quinn.
Conveniently, Saga has built up enough of a rapport with Walter (or has she, and is he playing them again?) that he mentions the last time he felt free was at Hopewell River Gorge. Jonah decides to follow that clue to the one place where you can see the gorge, as Michael insists he and Ida finish their game of hangman, which is actually a message from the Sandman. If Ida kills herself, “he’ll bring Felicia back.” Cut to black.
Apple TV’s Nocturne Episode 5 keeps the mystery central while letting the performances shine.

It’s a cool place for the episode to end, but I wish the emotional climax here was stronger, and I think the disconnect comes down to Ida. I’m not sure if the disconnect comes from Metz’s performance or certain lines of dialogue that just don’t work or a combination of both, but Ida’s reaction feels a bit overdone, and it robs what should be an excellent closing scene of its emotional bite.
“Solitude” is still good television, though, and Nocturne’s commitment to the episode’s gimmick – that everyone is alone, dealing with their own stuff, even when they’re all in the same room – really pays off. Even smaller moments, such as Quinn’s angry phone conversation about missing a custody meeting, really add to the sense of both physical and emotional separation these characters have from each other. That it does all of this while keeping the core mystery moving is even more impressive.
Maybe more surprises await us at Hopewell River Gorge. Maybe it’s another trick. Maybe we’ll learn whether Jonah planted that evidence. Maybe we won’t. I’m not sure what matters as much as the “how” at this point, and if Nocturne can continue to nail the how, well… anything’s possible. See you next week.
Nocturne Episode 5 is streaming now, exclusively on Apple TV with new episodes every Friday.
Previous Episode | Next Episode
“Solitude” is still good television, though, and Nocturne’s commitment to the episode’s gimmick – that everyone is alone, dealing with their own stuff, even when they’re all in the same room – really pays off.






