I still remember my first time hearing a college marching band. I grew up a Penn State fan; it runs in the family, and hearing “Fight On, State” for the first time immediately hooked me. Fast forward over 20 years, and that excitement led me to march snare drum for four years and kept me teaching high school percussion for over a decade. And yet, whenever I’m watching a college football game, I’m drawn to the bands in the same way I was before I ever picked up a pair of sticks.
These traditions have been pulling in football fans and band kids for generations. The bands can make us teary-eyed when we hear our alma mater, or they can get us hyped up when we hear the opening hit in “Neck.” That’s what makes a video game like EA Sports College Football 27 such a big deal for marching band. It drops 138 schools in front of millions of people who will never set foot on 137 of those campuses. No band program on earth gets a stage like that.
Get BWT in your inbox!
Get BWT in your inbox!
Credit where it’s due. EA knows what it has. When Design Director Christian Brandt laid out the pageantry work in College Football 27, he talked about a Saturday that starts way before kickoff. “It starts with the band,” he said. Hard to argue with that.
And they put money behind it. EA assembled the EA SPORTS Marching Band, 113 collegiate musicians, and cut 25 new songs with them. Nineteen are marching band covers recorded in Nashville, running from Metallica to Dr. Dre and Snoop Dogg to Sabrina Carpenter. Zach Bryan’s touring band sat in. Somebody in that building also decided the world needed marching arrangements of Battlefield, Mass Effect, Command & Conquer, and Madden NFL, and honestly? They were right.
College football is nothing without the marching band.
The standout, though, is actual college kids. The Carolina Band out of South Carolina won Metallica’s national competition, “For Whom the Band Tolls,” off their halftime show from last October’s Oklahoma game. They ran Metallica’s own marching charts of “Master of Puppets” and “Lux Aeterna,” then closed with an “Enter Sandman” arrangement written by a grad assistant from their own School of Music. Robert Trujillo announced the win on an Instagram story in January. Fifty grand to the band. EA rolled a recording truck to Columbia to get it on tape.
Their playing is what hits you on the Press Start screen. Their “Sad But True” is in the menus. Real band kids playing in the game. And then the whole thing goes quiet. Not literally. The band’s still there, still audible, still doing band things. But it never once yanked me off the couch the way a real one does. It’s wallpaper.
Start with the uniforms, which are generic. Band uniforms carry a program’s history the exact same way a jersey does, and they change on the exact same timeline, which is to say almost never, and always for a reason people are still mad about twenty years later. What’s on the field in College Football 27 is a costume. Anybody who’s sweated through one of those wool jackets in September will clock it in four seconds.
EA Sports College Football 27 honors game days, but you can’t do that without the Saturday sound.
Now look at what EA counted this year. Fifty-five schools with updated runout pyros. More than 90 team chants added or reworked. Thirty-five new mascots. Thirty-plus student section banners. The band? Thirty-two new runout tunnels, which are the formations the players sprint out between, plus a shrug of “more band formations.” Meanwhile, the equipment guys shipped hanging mouthpieces, smaller shoulder pads, clear reflective visors, and waist-worn playcall sheets. But band uniforms aren’t on the list anywhere.
Then there’s the marching. The bands step out of time. That is the whole job. Everything else a band does revolves around that one skill. It’s the first thing they teach you at band camp and the last thing you stop getting screamed at about. You can play like the Chicago Symphony, and it does not matter one bit if your left foot lands on two.
Heck, I can’t even walk through Publix without walking in time to the music. I won’t pretend to be a master programmer, but I’d imagine it’s harder to make them all move randomly than to sync them up. It’s a fix EA should prioritize.
College Football 27 only exists because EA figured out how to pay college students to be themselves. The series died in 2013 under lawsuits about using player likenesses without cutting anybody a check. NIL brought it back. EA sent offers to more than 11,000 players before College Football 25: six hundred bucks and a copy of the game, and 10,000 of them said yes inside eight days.
Marching bands are more than set dressing in college football; they’re the Stadium Pulse.
By College Football 26, the number was up to $1,500, with $16.5 million committed to base payments, the biggest single-sport NIL deal ever done. Eleven thousand college kids. Named, paid, out on the field. And the band standing forty feet away is a session ensemble from Nashville covering all 138 schools at once.
That’s why so much of the music comes out generic. One great band cannot sound like 138 bands, because 138 bands don’t sound alike. That’s the entire point of them. An SEC drumline and a Big Ten drumline are not doing the same job in different colors.
EA already ran the pilot. The Carolina Band got fifty grand and a truck, and now they’re the first thing you hear when you boot the game. It worked. Once. As a contest prize. So picture the version where it isn’t a prize. Most bands already record themselves for a variety of reasons. EA could help secure recording equipment for those who don’t already have it.
They would say yes before you finished the question. Ten thousand football players signed in eight days. Go find a band program that would turn down a check and a chance to be in the game. Cut the programs a check and hand the kids a copy, same as the quarterback.
CFB 27 doesn’t honor HBCUs, and with that, it doesn’t bring history to a cornerstone of football.
And then there’s the part that flat out stinks. College Football 27 has 138 playable teams, and every last one is FBS. No FCS schools. That makes sense. Adding entire lower divisions would be a massive lift. But every HBCU football program in the country plays at the FCS or Division II level. Pageantry
So the Bayou Classic isn’t in College Football 27. Southern’s Human Jukebox and Grambling State’s World-Famed Tiger Marching Band aren’t in it. Neither is Florida A&M’s Marching 100, a band that’s been around since 1892 and gets credit for more than 30 innovations that other programs now run as standard practice.
The Bayou Classic packs the Caesars Superdome every Thanksgiving weekend. Andscape counted better than 67,000 seats filled by halftime of the 2018 edition. And the Battle of the Bands the night before is its own ticketed event in that same building, because down there the bands sell out a dome by themselves. No football required.
I get the math. There are 128 FCS programs playing in 2026, and every one means rosters, stadiums, licensing, and money somebody has to justify upstairs. But it would be a substantially cheaper way to reach out to these iconic bands and add them to the game.
The marching bands we love today at every FBS school are built on the foundation of pageantry, innovation, and energy that was defined by HBCU marching bands. Pageantry is core to the EA Sports College Football games, which means that the history behind that atmosphere should be too.
More Like Saturday is EA’s own north star, and by their own telling, Saturday starts with the band. They’re right. They’re just not done. The bands in College Football 27 are better than last year, and last year beat the year before that. The Carolina Band proved the model works. What’s left is everything after the tunnel.
So, EA Sports, put some history back in the uniforms and get the feet on the beat. Then make the bands the same offer EA already made to eleven thousand football players, because the kid on center snare earned that spot the same way the starting quarterback did. It might be a pipe dream, but you can’t put a price tag on what makes college football truly special.
EA Sports College Football 27 is available now on PC, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X|S.
