Close Menu
  • Login
  • Support Us
  • Newsletter
  • News
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
    • Video Games
      • Previews
      • PC
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X/S
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Xbox One
      • PS4
      • Tabletop
    • Film
    • TV
    • Anime
    • Comics
      • BOOM! Studios
      • Dark Horse Comics
      • DC Comics
      • IDW Publishing
      • Image Comics
      • Indie Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • Oni-Lion Forge
      • Valiant Comics
      • Vault Comics
  • Podcast
  • More
    • Event Coverage
    • BWT Recommends
    • RSS Feeds
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Support Us
But Why Tho?
RSS Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube
Trending:
  • Features
    Cosmic Spider-Man card details

    [EXCLUSIVE PREVIEW] The Spider-Man Set Gets A 5-Color Legendary Spider

    09/02/2025
    Lee Corso from College Football GameDay in EA Sports games

    EA Sports Always Understood Lee Corso’s Legacy

    09/01/2025
    Peacemaker Season 2 Episode 2 But Why Tho 10

    Spider-Man Is Coming To Magic And It’s Just Like The Comics

    08/29/2025
    Star Wars Visions Volume 3 Black

    ‘Black’ Sets The Tone For A Bold New Mixtape In ‘Star Wars Visions: Volume 3’

    08/28/2025
    Olivia Colman in The Roses

    ‘The Roses’ Is A Reimagining, Not A Remake, And That’s Why It Works So Well

    08/27/2025
  • Indie Games
  • K-Dramas
  • Netflix
  • Apple TV+
But Why Tho?
Home » Film » REVIEW: ‘What She Said’ Is All That Matters

REVIEW: ‘What She Said’ Is All That Matters

Jason FlattBy Jason Flatt09/15/20217 Mins ReadUpdated:01/16/2023
What She Said - But Why Tho
Share
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email
What She Said - But Why Tho

What She Said is a film by and starring Jenny Lester about her character Sam’s friends and family imposing a Friendsgiving on her about a year after she was raped. Some are there for different reasons: her brother (Britt Michael Gordon) is there to stop her from dropping the charges, her sister (Paige Berkovitz) to ensure he doesn’t get away with it, and some of her friends because, well, Eli brought them there on the promise of “normal” Friendsgiving.

For anybody reading this who knows me: don’t read this. It’s not about you, and neither is it for you to know about if you don’t already. So please just stop right here, thank you. For anybody reading this who doesn’t know me: I offer my experience to you freely not for pity or suggestions or justification for the review I’m about to give. I offer it simply in the hope that anybody who finds affinity with my experience in any way allows themselves the privilege of watching What She Said and, hopefully, getting from it the brief release that I did from it. I hope sharing my experience is helpful. I hope it isn’t selfish or gratuitous.

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here
Content Warning: This film and review included detailed descriptions of rape

I didn’t really understand until many years later, like, a few months ago, that the time that my then-girlfriend made me have sex with her at my grandpa’s shiva, and a number of other times, was rape. Honestly, even writing that sentence down feels like I’m lying or I’m making something up, exaggerating, or somehow full of shit. But that’s the whole thing with abuse and assault and violation of your autonomy. It breaks everything about you until you’re a husk of yourself and only if you’re lucky might you grow a new shell again and be safe inside a new self that’s loved and protected and fortified.

What She Said is perfect, because no matter how broken every person in it is, was, or will be, it’s a story about how none of it matters. Different choices or things that happen to them don’t determine whether they are good people or worthy of empathy and love. They’re perfect the way they are just for being. This is something I as a survivor certainly struggle with seeing in myself and people around me, but yet, I found immediate and unwavering solace in having masterfully depicted for the hour and a half that I watched this film.

It’s set in an idyllic mountain cabin that exudes decades of love and stories and unbreakable bonds, adorned with acoustic folk music constantly lyrically and attitudinally befitting every scene. So when all of that is juxtaposed against the screaming at one another that ensues as characters insist their perspective or their feelings are more important at any given moment, or the clear terrible communication the numerous couples possess becomes unbearably tense, the split emotions so beautifully acted by every character become visceral. You yearn for everyone to forgo their egos and love each other less caustically, but you also feel the anguish their love produces, whether it’s through Sam wanting all the people she loves to stop shoving their expectations onto her, or through her loved ones’ understandable frustration with how unreachable and unreasonable she seems.

It’s not about what everyone thinks or how they feel. But also, it is. Not in that it’s Sam’s job to make everyone feel better about what happened, that’s for them to sort out. But in that they’re the people who love her most, and for as much a right as she has to feel and act however she needs, she’s only going to have the chance to move on if she accepts the love she’s being given, broken as that love is. We can’t sit around waiting for people to love us exactly the way we need them to. We can’t make people be how they aren’t.

While select moments in What She Said are admittedly a bit Hallmarky in their delivery, the rest of the time it is just so well scripted and so well acted that by the end, the perhaps gratuitously poetic moments actually just felt real. The comedy of both the script and its delivery throughout keeps it from feeling melodramatic while the pointed Jewish-Millenialness of the family dynamic is also perfectly grounding for me, personally. They so much matched the subtle personality traits of everyone that I could truly and without second thought believe they might really happen. They also made me insanely jealous.

I get flashbacks still, all the time, nearly a decade later. And watching an idealized dramatization of somebody’s journey out from the darkest depths of themselves through the salvation of dear and dedicated loved ones was hard because I don’t have much of that. I’ve had my time of being interventioned by somebody who cares irrevocably about me, and continues to be lucky to have them, but they’re a signal pillar, not a whole support system like Sam has. And I’m lucky to have even that, compared to the unimaginable number of people who surely have less. It hurts a little bit, watching this perfect situation happen after something so terrible, even if it’s being handled by all accounts pretty miserably. It almost feels unrealistic, and that feels a bit despairful.

But, I also recognize the irony of comparing my trauma to the imaginative other who is worse off. And despite my jealousy and feeling like the unconditional love Sam receives is unrealistic, I still couldn’t help but be completely moved by the story and the conclusions its characters are able to come to. I truly credit the perfect set design, costuming, script, and acting for making me forget entirely about my own feelings and instead be moved by the feelings What She Said replaces them within its ideal reality. From whatever prior place you experience What She Said, just do so, and let Sam’s perspective wash over you. It’s a journey with a lot of twists and turns, so let it truly drive your emotions for you rather than try to predict where it’s going to go.

What She Said is not easy, but it’s also not about you. It’s about beautiful, broken people doing their best to hold each other close and hold each other up, even when how they do it is hurtful to themselves or to each other. It’s entirely perfect as the total imperfection of everything within the film offers the opportunity to reimagine what it can be to be alright again after the world is shattered, your body is taken away from you, and neither you nor your friends know how to help you put it back together in just the right way. Because there is no right way. And that’s alright. But it’ll only be alright if we let everything be alright and once we again let people, ourselves included, love us fiercely and unconditionally, even if that love isn’t always being done right. None of what happens in the movie is for granted, some of it may be fantasy, but all of it is exactly right because, in the end, Sam says it is.

What She Said is streaming now on video on demand.

What She Said
  • 10/10
    Rating - 10/10
10/10

TL:DR

What She Said is not easy, but it’s also not about you. It’s about beautiful, broken people doing their best to hold each other close and hold each other up, even when how they do it is hurtful to themselves or to each other.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
Previous ArticleTIFF 2021: Carolyn Talks ‘Terrorizers’ with Director Ho Wi Ding
Next Article REVIEW: ‘What If…?’ Episode 6
Jason Flatt
  • X (Twitter)

Jason is the Sr. Editor at But Why Tho? and producer of the But Why Tho? Podcast. He's usually writing about foreign films, Jewish media, and summer camp.

Related Posts

Choi Gyu-ri, Shin Eun-Soo in Love Untangled
7.5

REVIEW: ‘Love Untangled’ Is Just Adorable

08/31/2025
Austin Butler in Caught Stealing
8.5

REVIEW: ‘Caught Stealing’ Marks An Exciting Pivot for Darren Aronofsky

08/27/2025
Margaret Qualley stars as Honey O' Donahue in the film Honey Don't
8.5

REVIEW: ‘Honey Don’t!’ Is A Genius Work Of Subversion And Fantasy Fulfillment

08/25/2025
Benedict Cumberbatch in The Roses But Why Tho
5.0

 REVIEW: ‘The Roses’ Lacks A Thorny Edge

08/25/2025
Mert Ramazan Demir in Abandoned Man
6.5

REVIEW: ‘Abandoned Man’ Lacks Depth In Its Take On Betrayal

08/22/2025
Ne Zha 2 promotional still from a24
10.0

REVIEW: ‘Ne Zha 2’ Is One Of The Most Epic Feats Of Animation

08/21/2025

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here
TRENDING POSTS
Cosmic Spider-Man card details Features

[EXCLUSIVE PREVIEW] The Spider-Man Set Gets A 5-Color Legendary Spider

By Kate Sánchez09/02/2025Updated:09/02/2025

An exclusive look at a new 5-Color Spider entering Magic: The Gathering’s Spider-Man set, and Cosmic Spider-Man is going to be a tough one to take on.

Hololive EN at Radio City Music Hall Events

Hololive EN At Radio City Music Hall Was A Pure Expression Of Fandom

By Adrian Ruiz08/31/2025Updated:09/03/2025

Hololive EN turned Radio City in New York City into the pure expression of fandom: chants, penlights, and community in perfect sync.

Karl Anthony Towns in NBA 2k26 But Why Tho
8.5
PS5

REVIEW: ‘NBA 2K26’ Brings Basketball To Life

By Kyle Foley09/03/2025

NBA 2K26 combines improved visuals with some important tweaks to keep the series feeling fresh in the latest yearly release.

Cronos: The New Dawn Nest
8.0
PC

REVIEW: ‘Cronos: The New Dawn’ Does Post-Apocalyptic Psychological Horror Right

By Mick Abrahamson09/03/2025Updated:09/03/2025

While not particularly sacry, Cronos: The New Dawn is a lot of fun as a survival horror that puts you in the futuristic armor of the Traveler.

But Why Tho?
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest RSS YouTube Twitch
  • CONTACT US
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Review Score Guide
Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small contribution.
Written Content is Copyright © 2025 But Why Tho? A Geek Community

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

But Why Tho Logo

Support Us!

We're able to keep making content thanks to readers like YOU!
Support independent media today with
Click Here