Close Menu
  • Login
  • Support Us
  • Newsletter
  • News
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
    • Video Games
      • Previews
      • PC
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X/S
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Xbox One
      • PS4
      • Tabletop
    • Film
    • TV
    • Anime
    • Comics
      • BOOM! Studios
      • Dark Horse Comics
      • DC Comics
      • IDW Publishing
      • Image Comics
      • Indie Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • Oni-Lion Forge
      • Valiant Comics
      • Vault Comics
  • Podcast
  • More
    • Event Coverage
    • BWT Recommends
    • RSS Feeds
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Support Us
But Why Tho?
RSS Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube
Trending:
  • Features
    EA Sports Madden NFL 26 Head Coach But Why Tho 5

    Dear EA Sports, Why Can’t I Make A Hot Coach?

    08/14/2025
    Blade in Marvel Rivals Season 3.5

    Blade Can Shut Down The Other Team In Marvel Rivals Season 3.5 If You Know How

    08/08/2025
    John Cena and Cody Rhodes during Summerslam 2025

    The SummerSlam 2025 Main Event Was A Fever Dream We All Needed

    08/08/2025
    Street Fighter 6 Sagat

    Sagat Brings Depth And Approachability To ‘Street Fighter 6’

    08/07/2025
    Battlefield 6 Classes - Support trailer image

    Battlefield 6 Really Wants You To Play Support (But Knows You Won’t)

    07/31/2025
  • Indie Games
  • K-Dramas
  • Netflix
  • Apple TV+
But Why Tho?
Home » TV » REVIEW: ‘The Walking Dead: Dead City’ Season 2 Episode 3 – “Why Did the Mainlanders Cross the River?”

REVIEW: ‘The Walking Dead: Dead City’ Season 2 Episode 3 – “Why Did the Mainlanders Cross the River?”

vanessa makiBy vanessa maki05/19/20255 Mins Read
TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 promotional still
Share
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email

In the world of The Walking Dead, just about anything is possible and that includes introducing weird communities. After what was a mess of a second episode, The Walking Dead: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3, “Why Did the Mainlanders Cross the River?” is a tiny bit of an improvement.

During “Why Did the Mainlander Cross the River”, we get more of a glimpse into Hershel (Logan Kim)’s perspective during the present day and when he was held captive by the Croat (Zeljko Ivanek) and the Dama (Lisa Emery). Instead of being tortured, left to rot in a cell, or any other horrifying outcome that can come with being held captive, Hershel’s time with the Dama wasn’t that bad.

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

Throughout Season 1, we’re made to believe that Hershel was in dire circumstances the entire time. After all, he was taken from Maggie by people who are absolutely her enemies. We don’t fully understand why Hershel’s time spent with the Dama was profound enough to betray his own mother.

It could be due to Hershel’s resentment towards Maggie (Lauren Cohan) being so obsessed with Negan (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) his entire life. TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 highlights how Hershel doesn’t care about Negan because he wasn’t born when Glenn (Steven Yeun) was killed. Hershel has no connection to his father and Maggie has been projecting on him for as long as he can remember.

TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 explores New Babylon and shifts its tone.

TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 promotional still

When the episode isn’t focusing on Hershel’s perspective or Negan attacking his own group, we’re following New Babylon and this new group of Central Park people who are clearly a cult. The Walking Dead: Dead City’s tone has entirely shifted with the introduction of a Mother Nature praising group. During a chaotic and deadly run-in with walkers that surround the area, Hershel is separated from Maggie and New Babylon, leading him to meet a new friend. A friend who happens to be part of the same Mother Nature community. The weirdness continues from there.

TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 isn’t the worst episode of the season so far, but it’s certainly the weirdest and that might be somewhat off-putting to viewers. Not to mention, Navarez (Dascha Polanco) continues to be a horribly written character, and Dead City‘s problem with side characters continues.

When the Mother Nature group declines New Babylon’s offer to join them, Navarez tells Pearlie (Gaius Charles) they should force them to join. It’s certainly a choice to make Navarez this unlikable to the point where we don’t care what happens to her.  TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 fails to give in the way the previous episode did with these characters.

Maggie’s motivations keep wavering, and that doesn’t work.

TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 promotional still

As far as the main characters go, it’s more of the same for Negan as well as Maggie. Failing to take that last step in making Negan a full-blown villain again is doing a disservice to this season. If Negan refused to put on a performance in “Power Equals Power”, it would make more sense for him to be wishy-washy.

Just like if Maggie were to declare that she’s done with Negan, only to be lying to herself, would make her obsessively asking Hershel about what happened when he saw him a little less annoying. At this point there should be a clear direction for Negan and Maggie’s individual motivations, outside of killing or saving each other.

Closer to the end of the episode, Negan fails to lie convincingly to the Croat, after murdering one of the members of their group. It’s relatively out of character because Negan should be better at this overall. But the Croat clearly has hidden agendas and is likely planning to go against the Dama, who is probably several steps ahead of him.

It’s safe to say that Negan’s group isn’t nearly as dull as New Babylon’s strange approach to leadership. Would it make much of a difference if Negan decides to betray them and join New Babylon? Probably not. And that’s somewhat of a problem because these communities should more interesting than that.

A slight improvement from the last, Dead City Season 2 Episode 3, is still struggling to balance Negan.

TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 promotional still

Thankfully, the episode has some intriguing visuals and a few gory moments that distract from the silly writing and overall eyeroll-inducing moments. There’s even a moment where a dead and pointlessly introduced character’s heart is carved out of their chest and fed to walkers.

The Mother Nature group (they have no official name) is weird and feels like they belong in one of the later seasons of The Walking Dead, but why are they feeding hearts to walkers? It’s a question that likely won’t get answered, but it’s still a question to ask nonetheless.

TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 is still better than Episode 2, and some of that is due to Hershel’s flashbacks because of the Dama’s manipulation of him. Appealing to his artistic abilities and introducing him to treats he’s never experienced before is sinister. But that falls in line with the Dama and how she’s effortlessly sinister in her presence as a character. It’ll make Hershel’s potential betrayal of Maggie quite the spectacle, and she’ll regret the rift she unconsciously crafted between them. Especially since Negan will be to blame in the end.

The Walking Dead: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 is available to stream on AMC or AMC+.

Previous Episode | Next Episode
The Walking Dead: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3
  • 6.5/10
    Rating - 6.5/10
6.5/10

TL;DR

TWD: Dead City Season 2 Episode 3 is still better than Episode 2, and some of that is due to Hershel’s flashbacks because of the Dama’s manipulation of him. Appealing to his artistic abilities and introducing him to treats he’s never experienced before is sinister.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
Previous ArticleAnno 117: Pax Romana Creative Director Talks New Players, Choice, And Building For Post-Launch
Next Article Official Vindictus: Defying Fate Alpha Test Dates Now Revealed
vanessa maki

Vanessa Maki is a queer Blerd and freelance writer. She has written for publications like Dread Central, Daily Dead, Fangoria, Screensphere and more. She's a former regular contributor for Pink Advocate as well as The Mary Sue, and currently writes for a few places.

Related Posts

Alien Earth Episode 1 and Episode 2 still from FX and Hulu
9.5

REVIEW: ‘Alien: Earth’ Episode 1-2 — “Neverland” and “Mr. October”

08/18/2025
Vanessa Kirby in Night Always Comes on Netflix But Why Tho
5.0

REVIEW: ‘Night Always Comes’ Lacks Purpose

08/16/2025
Foundation Season 3 Episode 6 promotional still
8.0

RECAP: ‘Foundation’ Season 3 Episode 6 — “The Shape of Time”

08/15/2025
Butterfly first look images from Prime Video
9.0

REVIEW: ‘Butterfly’ Continues Prime Video’s Spy Thriller Streak

08/13/2025
Trigger promotional image from Netflix
8.0

REVIEW: ‘Trigger’ Is Netflix’s Most Disturbing Series

08/08/2025
Foundation Season 3 Episode 5 promo image from AppleTV+
7.0

RECAP: ‘Foundation’ Season 3 Episode 5 — “Where Tyrants Spend Eternity”

08/08/2025

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here
TRENDING POSTS
Still from Shin Godzilla
8.5
Film

REVIEW: ‘Shin Godzilla’ Is More Relevant Than Ever

By Sarah Musnicky08/16/2025Updated:08/17/2025

It is understandable how Shin Godzilla succeeded at the box office nearly a decade ago. The strength of its story still stands today.

Botanical Bliss Update Palia But Why Tho 5 News

Palia’s New Botanical Bliss Update Brings New Flora, Decorations, And Quest Mechanic

By Matt Donahue08/18/2025Updated:08/18/2025

The Botanical Bliss update adds new event, more plushes, and a host of quality-of-life improvements and more to celebrate 2 years of Palia.

BOOTS Netflix First Look promotional images News

First Look at Coming-of-Age Story BOOTS, Coming to Netflix This October

By But Why Tho?08/17/2025

Netflix is reporting for duty this fall with the new eight-episode series BOOTS, a comedic drama starring Miles Heizer and Vera Farmiga

Nuestra Magia Secret Lair Art Interviews

EXCLUSIVE: How The ‘Nuestra Magia’ Secret Lair Found Its Identity And Raised Over $1M

By Kate Sánchez08/15/2025Updated:08/15/2025

We spoke with Ovidio Cartagena about Magic: The Gathering’s Nuestra Magia Secret Lair drop, its impact, and the real treasure within.

But Why Tho?
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest RSS YouTube Twitch
  • CONTACT US
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Review Score Guide
Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small contribution.
Written Content is Copyright © 2025 But Why Tho? A Geek Community

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

But Why Tho Logo

Support Us!

We're able to keep making content thanks to readers like YOU!
Support independent media today with
Click Here