Close Menu
  • Login
  • Support Us
  • Newsletter
  • News
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
    • Video Games
      • Previews
      • PC
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X/S
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Xbox One
      • PS4
      • Tabletop
    • Film
    • TV
    • Anime
    • Comics
      • BOOM! Studios
      • Dark Horse Comics
      • DC Comics
      • IDW Publishing
      • Image Comics
      • Indie Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • Oni-Lion Forge
      • Valiant Comics
      • Vault Comics
  • Podcast
  • More
    • Event Coverage
    • BWT Recommends
    • RSS Feeds
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Support Us
But Why Tho?
RSS Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube
Trending:
  • Features
    Momo and Okarun share a close moment in Dandadan

    Momo And Okarun: The Gold Standard For Shonen Romance

    07/03/2025
    Ironheart Episodes 4 6 But Why Tho 1

    ‘Ironheart’ Explained: Explore MCU’s Bold New Chapter

    07/01/2025
    Buck in 9-1-1

    ‘9-1-1’ Has To Let Buck Say Bisexual

    06/29/2025
    Nintendo Welcome Tour promotional image of the maraca mini-game

    The One “Game” That Justifies The Nintendo Switch 2 Purchase

    06/25/2025
    Destiel Confession in Supernatural - Castiel (Misha Collins) and Dean (Jensen Ackles)

    The Destiel Confession: The Lasting Importance Of Supernatural’s Greatest Ship

    06/22/2025
  • Squid Game
  • K-Dramas
  • Netflix
  • Switch 2 Games
  • Summer Game Fest
But Why Tho?
Home » Film » REVIEW: ‘Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar’ Hits an Empty Note

REVIEW: ‘Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar’ Hits an Empty Note

Kate SánchezBy Kate Sánchez08/20/20226 Mins ReadUpdated:08/26/2022
Fullmetal Alchemist
Share
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email

Fullmetal Alchemist

I feel obligated to start this review by saying I’m not actually against live-action anime films. In fact, there are a plethora of them that have come out historically and recently that absolutely rock. That said,  Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar marks the second time that this iconic franchise about brotherhood, scientific ethics, and the traumas of war has been stripped of the things that made it special in a live-action story. In this sequel to the 2017 live-action, Fullmetal Alchemist, a mysterious figure named Scar starts to target State Alchemists for their sins against God – and believe me, the actual punishment for the Ishvalan genocide is light here. Caught up in it all, Alchemist Edward Elric (Ryôsuke Yamada) and his brother Alphonse (Mackenyu) are at their most vulnerable, meanwhile, the Homunculi begin to unveil themselves once again.

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

The film is directed by Fumihiko Sori with a screenplay written by Sori and Takeshi Miyamoto adapted from Hiromu Arakawa‘s seminal manga. It has a stacked cast, staring Ryôsuke Yamada, Dean Fujioka, Keisuke Watanabe, Keisuke Watanabe, Tsubasa Honda, Atom Mizuishi, Mackenyu, and Seiyô Uchino.

Like the film before it Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar takes a lot of liberties, and unlike the feature film before it, this sequel struggles in balancing the special and practical effects. While I wouldn’t say the first of the Fullmetal Alchemist live-action movies was great, it was fun enough to go along for the ride at least through the first two acts. The Revenge of Scar, however, well it’s a hot mess that misses what makes the Ishvalan storyline in the franchise so important.

The reason that Scar, despite his iconic and towering presence in the manga and anime, is rather weak in the feature film that bears his name, is because of every misstep made in the first live-action film. By trying to map Scar into this new narrative, the sequel film has to do some serious backtracking and even more deviation from important story beats that make Scar who he is which were changed for the previous film. And, when included, remove the weight of them, given how the first film completely fumbled the Ishavalan genocide. Additionally, the film holds back on the scathing critique of racism and fascism that is the core of the source material, instead aiming for something more fantastical and without teeth. Sure, we see a little pressure put on the State Alchemists, but none as faith-shaking as is needed for the core of characters like Mustang.

Now, Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar isn’t without some fun, namely where Ed and Al are concerned. The effects that were used to bring Al to life are still some of the best and Ed’s wig is 10 times better than in the first film. And of course, their chemistry is one that actually holds your focus. Additionally, the action sequences between Ed, Al, and pretty much any of their opponents are visually well done. This is extended to Lin’s physical performance in action sequences that at least keep the entire film from becoming stale. Since they are the core that this film’s narrative spins around, sometimes that’s enough to hold your attention.

Additionally, Dean Fujioka returns as Roy Mustang and Misako Renbutsu as Hawkeye. While some moments are off, due to the writing, the dynamic that the two bring, however small, is one of the film’s bright spots. That said, the characters that surround these three are wooden at worst and messily held together at best (except for maybe Winry’s arc of forgiveness). Add in some truly odd choices in casting like aging up May Chang (Monroe Ron) yet keeping her entirely infantilized and this is a rocky ride.

I don’t have it in me to write 1000 words on why you should skip Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar. But what I do have in me is to point out that this film aims for visual accuracy as much as it can, including a ridiculously bulbous bald cap and airbrushed muscles for Armstrong. While faithfulness sometimes works, like with Ed and Al, and even the Homunculi, other times, like when Armstrong is trying to have an emotional confrontation with Mustang, the absolute absurdity of it all makes the story buckle. In fact, the only thing that Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar is focused on being faithful to is aesthetics that it refuses to capture the heart of the series it is adapting.

Fullmetal Alchemist The Revenge of Scar - But Why Tho

Fullmetal Alchemist as a franchise is visually stunning, but none of the visual beauty overshadows its message. Here, however, all of the pain that Scar feels, his trauma, and the empathetic connections he makes in the source material are thrown out and replaced with bombastic elements. While there is an attempt to show Scar’s humanity, past, and complexity in the final act, it’s a little too late and too surface level to really drive home the importance of the character within the larger narrative of Fullmetal Alchemist. Additionally, there isn’t enough internal exploration from the state alchemists about the roles they played in the genocide of Ishvala, only small gestures that show they know it was wrong.

That’s where Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar misses the mark completely. A good cast with a great visual style means nothing unless it’s backed up with heart. When you look at the film by itself, detached from the larger narrative of Fullmetal Alchemist or even just what was established in its predecessor, The Revenge of Scar is passable, if only barely. Ed and Al’s connection, as well as the relationship between Mustang and Hawks, are the shining moments in an overstuffed film.

But if you come into it with any expectation of an emotional pay-off based on what you know from the manga or the anime, then you’re going to be beyond disappointed. With a clear setup for the third film, I truly don’t know what will happen next.

Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar is streaming exclusively on Netflix with the third film releasing on the streaming platform in September.

Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar
  • 4/10
    Rating - 4/10
4/10

TL;DR

When you look at the film by itself, detached from the larger narrative of Fullmetal Alchemist or even just what was established in its predecessor, The Revenge of Scar is passable, if only barely. Ed and Al’s connection, as well as the relationship between Mustang and Hawks, are the shining moments in an overstuffed film. But if you come into it with any expectation of emotional pay-off based on what you know from the manga or the anime, then you’re going to be beyond disappointed.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
Previous ArticleREVIEW: ‘Kirby’s Dream Buffet’ Is Fine But It’s No Feast (Switch)
Next Article 10 Wholesome Shounen Ai to Read Right Now
Kate Sánchez
  • Website
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram

Kate Sánchez is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of But Why Tho? A Geek Community. There, she coordinates film, television, anime, and manga coverage. Kate is also a freelance journalist writing features on video games, anime, and film. Her focus as a critic is championing animation and international films and television series for inclusion in awards cycles. Find her on Bluesky @ohmymithrandir.bsky.social

Related Posts

The Old Guard 2
5.5

REVIEW: ‘The Old Guard 2’ Is Distracted And Half-Baked

07/02/2025
Scarlett Johansson and Jonathan Bailey in Jurassic World: Rebirth
5.5

REVIEW: ‘Jurassic World: Rebirth’ Is Best When Nobody Is Talking

06/30/2025
MEGAN 2.0 promotional image
7.0

REVIEW: ‘M3GAN 2.0’ Puts Action First

06/29/2025
F1 (2025) promotional key art
8.0

REVIEW: ‘F1’ Is A High-Octane Blockbuster

06/24/2025
KPop Demon Hunters Promotional image form Netflix
9.0

REVIEW: ‘KPop Demon Hunters’ Brings Beautiful Animation And An Even Better Message

06/20/2025
Aaron Taylor-Johnson and Alfie Williams in 28 Years Later
8.5

REVIEW: ’28 Years Later’ Is How Franchises Should Return

06/18/2025

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here
TRENDING POSTS
Taecyeon and Seohyun in The First Night With The Duke Episodes 7-8
7.5
TV

REVIEW: ‘The First Night With The Duke’ Episodes 7-8

By Sarah Musnicky07/03/2025

The First Night With The Duke Episodes 7-8 spends welcome time in pre-domestic bliss before new developments stir up trouble.

Together (2025) still from Sundance
8.0
Film

REVIEW: Have A Grossly Good Time ‘Together’

By Kate Sánchez01/27/2025Updated:07/04/2025

Dave Franco and Alison Brie’s Together (2025) is disgustingly funny, genuinely ugly, and just a good time at the movies.

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 and 4 Alcatraz
9.0
PS5

REVIEW: ‘Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3 + 4’ Gives Old Games New Life

By Kyle Foley07/07/2025

Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 and 4 is another example of how to breathe new life into a classic without losing touch of what makes the originals great.

Black Women Anime — But Why Tho (9) BWT Recommends

10 Black Women in Anime That Made Me Feel Seen

By LaNeysha Campbell11/11/2023Updated:12/03/2024

Black women are some of anime’s most iconic characters, and that has a big impact on Black anime fans. Here are some of our favorites.

But Why Tho?
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest RSS YouTube Twitch
  • CONTACT US
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Review Score Guide
Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small contribution.
Written Content is Copyright © 2025 But Why Tho? A Geek Community

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

But Why Tho Logo

Support Us!

We're able to keep making content thanks to readers like YOU!
Support independent media today with
Click Here