Close Menu
  • Login
  • Support Us
  • Newsletter
  • News
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
    • Video Games
      • Previews
      • PC
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X/S
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Xbox One
      • PS4
      • Tabletop
    • Film
    • TV
    • Anime
    • Comics
      • BOOM! Studios
      • Dark Horse Comics
      • DC Comics
      • IDW Publishing
      • Image Comics
      • Indie Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • Oni-Lion Forge
      • Valiant Comics
      • Vault Comics
  • Podcast
  • More
    • Event Coverage
    • BWT Recommends
    • RSS Feeds
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Support Us
But Why Tho?
RSS Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube
Trending:
  • Features
    Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 Co-Op and weapon kit promotional image from Treyarch and Raven Studios

    Sharing Gunsmith Builds in Black Ops 7 Is About To Get Much Easier

    08/19/2025
    EA Sports Madden NFL 26 Head Coach But Why Tho 5

    Dear EA Sports, Why Can’t I Make A Hot Coach?

    08/14/2025
    Blade in Marvel Rivals Season 3.5

    Blade Can Shut Down The Other Team In Marvel Rivals Season 3.5 If You Know How

    08/08/2025
    John Cena and Cody Rhodes during Summerslam 2025

    The SummerSlam 2025 Main Event Was A Fever Dream We All Needed

    08/08/2025
    Street Fighter 6 Sagat

    Sagat Brings Depth And Approachability To ‘Street Fighter 6’

    08/07/2025
  • Indie Games
  • K-Dramas
  • Netflix
  • Apple TV+
But Why Tho?
Home » Books » ADVANCED REVIEW: ‘The Lost Apothecary’

ADVANCED REVIEW: ‘The Lost Apothecary’

Jason FlattBy Jason Flatt02/21/20214 Mins ReadUpdated:06/28/2025
The Lost Apothecary - But Why Tho?
Share
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email

The Lost Apothecary - But Why Tho?
The Lost Apothecary is a historical fiction novel by Sarah Penner published by Park Row Books, an imprint of Harlequin, a subsidiary of HarperCollins. The audiobook is published by Harlequin Audio and is narrated by Lorna Bennett, Lauren Anthony, and Lauren Irwin.

In the late 1700s in London, a women’s apothecary Nella kept a book. In that book: the names of women who solicited her poisons to kill men who wronged them. In modern London, Caroline is visiting London for what is supposed to be her 10th wedding anniversary, but instead, she is getting as far away from her husband as possible, having just discovered his infidelity.

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

The chapters of The Lost Apothecary rotate between three voices: Nella, an ailing apothecary of women’s remedies who doubles as a dispenser of poisons; Eliza, a 12-year-old whose faith becomes entangled with Nella’s when she picks up poison on behalf of her mistress; and Caroline, a modern protagonist whose unfaithful husband is the absolute worst type of man and finds herself unexpectedly uncovering Nella and Eliza’s history for the first time.

The three-point of view characters have distinct voices (literally, with three different readers in the audio narration) but share a universal disposition. Nella has an air of wisdom with a tinge of assumption, which mixes well with Eliza’s confident naivety. And Caroline is adrift, not as sure about anything as the other two besides that her life needs a total reboot. All three women, though, are living in the shadow of men, their atrocities, and balancing the expectation and allure of motherhood. Infidelity, abandonment, and, much worse, don’t only traumatize the main characters, the men in their lives nearly completely ruin them forever. Secret poisons sound almost alluring.

Writing multiple perspectives over different time periods takes a lot to ensure every character’s story is equally compelling. The perspectives do all work together thematically and are individually interesting. But something is just slightly missing from both time periods to help fully bridge them. It’s perhaps the lack of a true mystery, at least, until the very last minute, in the present-day story that keeps the two sides of The Lost Apothecary feeling like two separate stories for much of the book. They’re both enjoyable stories on their own, but I wish there was just a smidgen more that would keep me in an elevated state of intrigue over what would happen next.

Again, both halves are indeed compelling on their own. Caroline’s plight with her husband, budding new friendship in England, and adrenalized pursuit of self-determination is both intense and gratifying. I detest her husband entirely and was repeatedly triggered by his behavior as it so immediately reflected emotional abuse I’ve sustained in my own relationship history. If Penner was not writing from her own personal experience, she was certainly drawing from a powerfully recognizable well. But for as uncomfortable as I was on occasion, Caroline’s absolute not just resilience but total imperturbable momentum right through him is perfect.

Nella and Eliza’s intergenerational relationship is very appreciable as well. While there isn’t necessarily affection between them, you can sense strong mutual admiration lacing their interactions. Eliza especially is written aptly as a 12-year old. Rather than the infallible tween of so many stories, she is totally as unwitting a child as a 12-year-old girl in the 1790s would be while still as headstrong as any child deserves to be.

And while there is a clear throughline between Caroline’s discovery of an apothecary vial and her quest to discover its story and the lives of Nella and Eliza, it just never feels like a mystery. It’s clear this adventure is significant to Caroline, who once dreamt of studying at Cambridge and becoming a historian. But it’s not necessarily lived through the book’s narrative and structure so much as told through Caroline’s chapters alone. It’s a totally compelling story, but because the mystery for nearly the whole book is “who is this apothecary” and the reader already knows the answer to that question, there isn’t an opportunity to feel the same high of uncovering a long-kept secret that Caroline experiences herself.

The Lost Apothecary is a good story from three perspectives displaced by several centuries, bound by the universal shadow of abusive men. While I wish there was just a sliver more suspense or mystery to keep the momentum between the two time periods, each side of the book holds its own with decent and empathetic characters.

The Lost Apothecary is available wherever books are sold on March 2nd.

The Lost Apothecary
4

TL;DR

The Lost Apothecary is a good story from three perspectives displaced by several centuries, bound by the universal shadow of abusive men. While I wish there was just a sliver more suspense or mystery to keep the momentum between the two time periods, each side of the book holds its own with decent and empathetic characters.

  • Buy now via our Bookshop.org affiliate link

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
Previous ArticleREVIEW: ‘Yashahime: Princess Half-Demon,’ Episode 20 – “The Hidden Village of Half Demons”
Next Article REVIEW: ‘It’s a Sin’ Is The Greatest Tragedy You Have To Watch
Jason Flatt
  • X (Twitter)

Jason is the Sr. Editor at But Why Tho? and producer of the But Why Tho? Podcast. He's usually writing about foreign films, Jewish media, and summer camp.

Related Posts

Jedi Battle Scars - But Why Tho

ADVANCED REVIEW: ‘Star Wars Jedi: Battle Scars’

02/22/2023
The Battle of Jedha - But Why Tho

REVIEW: ‘Star Wars: The High Republic: The Battle of Jedha’

01/04/2023
A Day of Fallen Night

ADVANCED REVIEW: ‘A Day of Fallen Night’ Is An Epic Tale

12/03/2022
High Republic Convergence - But Why Tho

REVIEW: ‘Star Wars: The High Republic: Convergence’

11/22/2022
Sensory Life on the Spectrum - But Why Tho

ADVANCED REVIEW: ‘Sensory: Life on the Spectrum’

10/17/2022
Star Wars: The Princess and the Scoundrel

ADVANCED REVIEW: ‘Star Wars: The Princess and the Scoundrel’

07/26/2022

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here
TRENDING POSTS
Still from Shin Godzilla
8.5
Film

REVIEW: ‘Shin Godzilla’ Is More Relevant Than Ever

By Sarah Musnicky08/16/2025Updated:08/17/2025

It is understandable how Shin Godzilla succeeded at the box office nearly a decade ago. The strength of its story still stands today.

Botanical Bliss Update Palia But Why Tho 5 News

Palia’s New Botanical Bliss Update Brings New Flora, Decorations, And Quest Mechanic

By Matt Donahue08/18/2025Updated:08/18/2025

The Botanical Bliss update adds new event, more plushes, and a host of quality-of-life improvements and more to celebrate 2 years of Palia.

BOOTS Netflix First Look promotional images News

First Look at Coming-of-Age Story BOOTS, Coming to Netflix This October

By But Why Tho?08/17/2025

Netflix is reporting for duty this fall with the new eight-episode series BOOTS, a comedic drama starring Miles Heizer and Vera Farmiga

Nuestra Magia Secret Lair Art Interviews

EXCLUSIVE: How The ‘Nuestra Magia’ Secret Lair Found Its Identity And Raised Over $1M

By Kate Sánchez08/15/2025Updated:08/15/2025

We spoke with Ovidio Cartagena about Magic: The Gathering’s Nuestra Magia Secret Lair drop, its impact, and the real treasure within.

But Why Tho?
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest RSS YouTube Twitch
  • CONTACT US
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Review Score Guide
Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small contribution.
Written Content is Copyright © 2025 But Why Tho? A Geek Community

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

But Why Tho Logo

Support Us!

We're able to keep making content thanks to readers like YOU!
Support independent media today with
Click Here