REVIEW: ‘Thor: Lightning and Lament,’ Issue #1

Thor: Lightning and Lament #1 is a one-shot published by Marvel Comics, written by Ralph Macchio, with art by Todd Nauck, colours by Rachelle Rosenberg, and letters by Joe Sabino. This story takes place in Thor’s early days on Earth following his exile from Asgard, living a double life as Doctor Donald Blake. But an emergency in his home means he must return to try and save it.

There is a classic feel to every aspect of this story, truly reliving the Stan Lee period of Thor’s time on Earth. With only one issue to tell this tale, Macchio fills a lot inside of it without making the comic feel cramped or rushed. The structure is superb, opening on Earth has Thor battles one of his most famous rogues before plunging straight into surgery as Donald. It helps identify when the story is happening and the new status quo. After that comes the call to Asgard, leading to an enormous battle. The scale of the fight is gigantic and epic. Whilst there are no major surprises to the story, the enjoyment comes from relieving this world. 

The characters have also been returned to their former selves, which should absolutely be celebrated even if it is just for a one-shot. It is fantastic seeing all of the classic Gods and Sagardians in the same place, whether that be Baldur, Thor’s noble brother, his lover Sif, or the Warriors Three. They may not be filled with depth, but they are incredibly fun. Similarly, Macchio’s dialogue has always befitted this style of comic as it can really tap into the cheesiness of the world. 

Just as Macchio is a perfect fit as a writer for this story, Nauck is also a brilliant choice as an artist. He has a classic influence that works beautifully when trying to recapture the look of an old tale in a new book. Thor is presented as huge, as are most of the Asgardians, his scale taking up most of the panels that he is in. Every costume is their original or most famous look, rife in detail. Speaking of details, Nauck’s illustration of the battle in the second half of the issue is jaw-dropping. There are individual bouts happening throughout the page, some in the farthest corner of the background. Yet Nauck presents it with stunning intricacy. Each warrior has their own armour that sets them apart from the fighter next to them.

The colours are stunning. With so much happening, Rosenberg’s work is crucial in picking out the most important details. All of the main fighters have a distinct colour that makes them stand out in the sea of chaos. They also have their signature colours which are rich and vibrant. This artist and colourist are frequent collaborators and it is so clear from the beauty of the pages. The font is primarily in the Asgardian typeface, which may be difficult for some to read, but fits the style of the comic.

Thor: Lightning and Lament #1 is a really fun adventure. It reminded me of what was excellent about the classic Thor stories. It is such an extravagant, joyous world that really celebrates fantasy. There isn’t necessarily anything new inside this issue, but just the set of circumstances within makes it enjoyable. The art and writing feel like a beautiful homage to the origins of this phenomenal character and the legendary creators that preceded them.

Thor: Lightning and Lament #1 is available where comics are sold.