Close Menu
  • Login
  • Support Us
  • Newsletter
  • News
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
    • Video Games
      • Previews
      • PC
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X/S
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Xbox One
      • PS4
      • Tabletop
    • Film
    • TV
    • Anime
    • Comics
      • BOOM! Studios
      • Dark Horse Comics
      • DC Comics
      • IDW Publishing
      • Image Comics
      • Indie Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • Oni-Lion Forge
      • Valiant Comics
      • Vault Comics
  • Podcast
  • More
    • Event Coverage
    • BWT Recommends
    • RSS Feeds
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Support Us
But Why Tho?
RSS Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube
Trending:
  • Features
    Marvel's Spider-Man Secret Lair promotional image

    Get a Look At the Secret Lair x Marvel’s Spider-Man Superdrop

    09/08/2025
    Starseeker: Astroneer Expeditions gameplay still

    Starseeker: Astroneer Expeditions Is All About Adventure (with Friends)

    09/08/2025
    Chord in Persona 5 The Phantom X

    Now Is The Perfect Time To Jump Back In ‘Persona 5: The Phantom X’

    09/05/2025
    Cosmic Spider-Man card details

    [EXCLUSIVE PREVIEW] The Spider-Man Set Gets A 5-Color Legendary Spider

    09/02/2025
    Lee Corso from College Football GameDay in EA Sports games

    EA Sports Always Understood Lee Corso’s Legacy

    09/01/2025
  • Indie Games
  • K-Dramas
  • Netflix
  • Apple TV+
But Why Tho?
Home » Film » REVIEW: Fantasy Island is Valentine’s Treat for Blumhouse Fans

REVIEW: Fantasy Island is Valentine’s Treat for Blumhouse Fans

Kate SánchezBy Kate Sánchez02/14/20205 Mins ReadUpdated:04/11/2023
Fantasy Island %E2%80%94 But Why Tho
Share
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email

Fantasy Island — But Why Tho

Fantasy Island has always been a story that has intrigued me. In the 1970s the debonaire Mexican actor Ricardo Montalbán as the island’s steward Mr. Raorke in his white suit fascinated me as much as the fantasies he brought to life on the island. So, when Blumhouse announced this remake of such a beloved cult title, I was intrigued, and when Michael Peña was announced as the enigmatic and seemingly immortal Mr. Roarke, I was excited.

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here

Much like the initial adaptation, Blumhouse’s Fantasy Island, directed by Jeff Wadlow, is focused on how fantasies twist around the individuals who dream them. With Mr. Roarke pulling the strings, five individuals have won a stay on the Island, a luxurious and remote tropical resort. Filled with promises and online rumors, each guest is tackling different parts of their psyches as they fulfill their wishes. For, Patrick (Austin Stowell), he’s looking to be a soldier, to finally enlist and serve, while Melanie (Lucy Hale) is looking to seek revenge on a school bully. Even still, JD (Ryan Hansen) and Brax (Jimmy O. Yang) just want to have it all and finally while Gwen (Maggie Q) is looking to have the family she always wanted.

While each of their fantasies begins as dreams, they quickly turn into nightmares as the guests abide by one of the two rules: follow their fantasy through to its natural conclusion. Along with the first rule, that each guest only receives one fantasy, this simple request reaches sinister ends as each guest is forced to survive their deepest desires. As elements of the story begin to weave together to form a larger narrative, Fantasy Island pays the viewers who draw the simplest conclusions while tangling itself in front of those who look deep into the twists expecting more subversive pay-offs.

Fantasy Island — But Why Tho (1)

Now, given the mysterious nature of the film, I can’t dive too much into the details of the film without spoiling major plot points. But, with twists for each character, for each group, and for each of their fantasies, there is almost too much going on. While some of the twists shine, others don’t really push the story anywhere. To put it simply, either 30 more minutes or a smaller ensemble could have helped push the narrative decisions for greater impact, but instead, many of them feel half-realized.

With that said, the character performances in the film carry it through some rough patches when their performances outshine the narrative weight of their fantasies. While the fantasies themselves each had great potential, only find themselves fully realized by leaning hard into their genre-bending motifs while the others are simply there. As showcased in the trailer, Melanie’s revenge leans in hard on the slasher angle, causing her and the bully she brought to the Island with her fantasy to move through the island as final girls. Second, you have Gwen’s emotional story of correcting her past and reclaiming a family she never thought she deserved. In Gwen, we see drama and even get a glimpse at Mr. Roarke’s compassionate core – a trait hidden for most of the film but known to fans of the original series.

Fantasy Island %E2%80%94 But Why Tho 2

But the joy of watching Blumhouse’s Fantasy Island isn’t because I expected it to be a narrative giant, but because I expected it to deliver just what it did: a love letter to the original. While many saw the trailer for Fantasy Island and quickly dubbed it the horror remake of a classic, the film, in reality, lives in the spirit of the original, while still embracing more thriller than camp tropes along the way. Mr. Roarke is now played by one of our generation’s iconic Mexican-American actors and Peña channels Montalbán wonderfully while still injecting his signature comedic charm in small moments. Additionally, while the narrative goes in many different directions with new characters popping up, old ones changing, and some not really meaning anything at all, it gets to the heart of the original series by unlocking a small moral tale and teaching the guests for better or worse.

While the middle of Fantasy Island is weirdly paced in its many twists, the ending solves its problems as the story finally becomes crystal clear and the film embraces its more overt nods to the original. I will say that the trailer shows a lot of the film, but almost all out of context, which means even those who spot a trailer’s nuance will find surprises in the film. Because of this, Fantasy Island is everything you want and expect from a theater Blumhouse film. It stumbles a bit but winds up where you need it to.

Propelled by its character performances, fans of Peña and popcorn movies will have fun with this title. After sitting with it, Fantasy Island is really all I ever needed it to be. It embraces the source material in the end, even it takes some time to get there. I’m sure a lot of people won’t like this flick, but it was a lot of absurd fun.

Fantasy Island is playing in theaters nationwide now.

Fantasy Island
  • 5/10
    Rating - 5/10
5/10

TL;DR

After sitting with it, Fantasy Island is really all I ever needed it to be. It embraces the source material in the end, even it takes some time to get there. I’m sure a lot of people won’t like this flick, but it was a lot of absurd fun.

  • Grab Tickets Using Our Fandango Affiliate Link

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
Previous ArticleThe Best Comic Book Couples of All Time
Next Article REVIEW: ‘Downhill’ (2020) for All the Tired, Long-Term Relationships
Kate Sánchez
  • Website
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram

Kate Sánchez is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of But Why Tho? A Geek Community. There, she coordinates film, television, anime, and manga coverage. Kate is also a freelance journalist writing features on video games, anime, and film. Her focus as a critic is championing animation and international films and television series for inclusion in awards cycles. Find her on Bluesky @ohmymithrandir.bsky.social

Related Posts

Miranda Cosgrove in The Wrong Paris
7.0

REVIEW: ‘The Wrong Paris’ Gets Streaming Rom-Coms Right

09/12/2025
Infinity Castle Demon Slayer Movie - promotional image from Crunchyroll
7.0

REVIEW: ‘Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba – The Movie: Infinity Castle’ Is Focused On Existing Fans

09/11/2025
The Long Walk (2025) film review promotional image
9.5

REVIEW: ‘The Long Walk’ Is The Most Heartfelt And Heartbreaking Stephen King Adaptation

09/11/2025
Natasha O’Keeffe in Whitetail
6.5

TIFF 2025: ‘Whitetail’ Is An Intimate View Of A Woman Stuck In Time

09/10/2025
Love Brooklyn
6.0

REVIEW: ‘Love, Brooklyn’ Rests on Pretty

09/10/2025
Park Jeong-min in The Ugly
7.0

TIFF 2025: ‘The Ugly’ Is A Harsh Exercise In Self-Reflection

09/09/2025

Get BWT in your inbox!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest and greated in entertainment coverage.
Click Here
TRENDING POSTS
The Long Walk (2025) film review promotional image
9.5
Film

REVIEW: ‘The Long Walk’ Is The Most Heartfelt And Heartbreaking Stephen King Adaptation

By Kate Sánchez09/11/2025Updated:09/11/2025

The Long Walk is a brutal watch. Equally heartfelt and heartbreaking, it’s one of the best adaptations of Stephen King’s work.

Foundation Season 3 Episode 10 promotional image from Apple TV+
9.0
TV

RECAP: ‘Foundation’ Season 3 Episode 10 — “The Darkness”

By Will Borger09/12/2025

Apple TV+’s Foundation Season 3 Episode 10 wasn’t a perfect episode of television, but it was a damn good one with a stacked cast.

EA Sports FC Icons Match promotional image from Nexon News

2025 Icons Match Returns With Football Legends Bridging The Pitch And Video Games

By Kate Sánchez09/03/2025Updated:09/03/2025

NEXON has announced the return of the ‘2025 Icons Match,’ a live event that brings a full roster of legendary players to the pitch.

Foundation Season 3 But Why Tho TV

REVIEW: Foundation Season 3 Is All About The Destination Not The Journey

By Will Borger09/12/2025

By the end, Foundation Season 3 was a very good season of television, but it often leaves you wishing it had more time to breathe.

But Why Tho?
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest RSS YouTube Twitch
  • CONTACT US
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Review Score Guide
Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small contribution.
Written Content is Copyright © 2025 But Why Tho? A Geek Community

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

But Why Tho Logo

Support Us!

We're able to keep making content thanks to readers like YOU!
Support independent media today with
Click Here